Carlotta's Masquerade costume:

Joan Sobel (Las Vegas - beautiful purlple color), Andrea Creighton (Singapore/World Tour - that skirt!), Corinne Schaefer (Hamburg), Patricia Hurd (US Tour)

Why who can this be?

World Tour cast:

Phantom: Brad Little

Christine: Claire Lyon (alt. Kristi Holden)

Raoul: Anthony Downing

Carlotta: Andrea Creighton

Firmin: John O'May

Andre: Jason Raphl

Madame Giry: Tina Walsh

Meg Giry: Eleanor Waite

Piangi: Thabiso Masemene

 Tiaras

1. Pauline du Plessis and Magdalene Minnaar, South Africa

2. Emilie Lynn and Andrea Creighton, World Tour

3. Anna Forbes and Layla Harrison, Royal Albert Hall

4. Anna O'Byrne, West End

5. Soot, Broadway 

6. Brianne Kelly Morgan, Las Vegas

7. Rebecca Caine, Toronto

8. Layla Harrison, West End

Claire Lyon and Andrea Creighton - before the Masquerade